by Legalnaija | Sep 15, 2026 | Blawg

Meet the Faculty: Yemisi Falaye
We’re excited to introduce Yemisi Falaye, Entertainment Lawyer with over 20 years of experience, as faculty at CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy.
Yemisi Falaye is an Entertainment Lawyer with over 20 years legal experience. She currently works at The Temple Company as Vice President, Legal and Business Development departments of the company. Prior to joining The Temple Company, Yemisi headed the Entertainment Law Group of the largest law firm in Nigeria, Dentons ACAS-Law.
‘Yemisi has over the years garnered in-depth experience in providing premium legal advice and representation to individuals and organisations in the entertainment industries in Nigeria, which include film, music, theatre, art, television, radio, publishing and digital media.
Yemisi can proudly boast of working with large number of clients across the entertainment industry namely, Ini Edo, D’banj, Bisola Aiyeola, Zlatan Ibile, Joeboy, Adekunle Gold, Kizz Daniel, Lilo Aderogba, Tolani, Cuppy, Simi, Seyi Shay, Vector, Toke Makinwa, Chike, Young Jonn, Sola Sobowale, Wande Coal, Funke Akindele, Poco Lee, Bad Boy Timz, Ms. DSF amongst others. She is regarded as one of the most influential entertainment lawyers in Nigeria.
Asides entertainment law, ‘Yemisi also has a wide-range experience in Intellectual Property, Real Estate, Immigration and Company Secretarial matters in Nigeria.
She’s teaching at CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy. Real experience. Real insight.

📅 28–29 October 2026 | NECA House, Alausa, Ikeja + Zoom
🔗 Register — link in bio: https://selar.com/11h84v18ag
#CTL2026 #LawlexisNG #EntertainmentLaw #MeetTheFaculty #NigerianLawyers
by Legalnaija | Sep 8, 2026 | Blawg

Corporate & Sports Law Specialist | Partner, Lithos Legal Consult | Director of Legal, Nigerian Youth Football Development League
Abiodun Sonaike, Esq. is a Nigerian legal practitioner and Corporate and Sports Law specialist with extensive experience in football regulation, sports contracts, dispute resolution, corporate advisory, and sports governance.
He is a Partner and Co-founder of Lithos Legal Consult, a law firm with a strong focus on Corporate and Sports Law. He also serves as the Director of Legal of the Nigerian Youth Football Development League and as International Legal Adviser to Kanu International Football Academy (KIFA).
Called to the Nigerian Bar in 2015 after obtaining his LL.B. from the University of Abuja and his B.L. from the Nigerian Law School, Lagos Campus, Mr. Sonaike commenced his legal career at Afe Babalola & Co. and subsequently worked with Musibau Adetunbi & Co. from 2016 to 2017.
His Sports Law practice covers football player contracts and transfers, FIFA regulations, training compensation and solidarity contribution, football dispute resolution, academy structures, sports governance, and regulatory compliance. He has also worked alongside Mr. Tosin Akinyemi in the celebrated football dispute Anthony Chineme v. Nasarawa United & Ors.
Beyond legal practice, Mr. Sonaike is regularly invited as a Guest Speaker at Sports Law programmes, seminars, and academic events in universities, including Obafemi Awolowo University and the University of Lagos, both physically and virtually. He is also the Editor of The Mundial, the 2018 FIFA World Cup Magazine, and the Executive Director of Enterprise Law Forum, a legal podcast produced by Lithos Legal Consult for business professionals and entrepreneurs.
He is an Executive Committee Member of the Sports, Entertainment and Media Committee of the Nigerian Bar Association Section on Business Law (NBA-SBL).
His professional interests lie at the intersection of Law, Football, Business, Governance and Sports Development, with a particular passion for using legal knowledge to strengthen the structure and sustainability of the sports industry.

Register for CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy
📅 Dates: 28–29 October 2026
📍 Venue: NECA House, Hakeem Balogun Street, Alausa, Ikeja, Lagos
💻 Format: Hybrid — attend physically or join via Zoom
Pricing:
Physical: ₦135,000 (Early Bird ₦100,000)
Virtual: ₦85,000 (Early Bird ₦60,000)
Group discount: 10% off for 3 or more registrations from one organisation
Early Bird pricing ends 30 September 2026.
Register now:
https://selar.com/11h84v18ag
For enquiries, reach us at lawlexisinternational@gmail.com or @lawlexisng.
by Legalnaija | Sep 5, 2026 | Blawg

CTL 2026: Everything You Need to Know Before You Register
If you’ve been following along with our content but haven’t registered yet, this post is for you. Here’s a straightforward breakdown of everything you need to know about CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy — no guesswork required.
What Is CTL 2026?
CTL 2026 is the latest edition of Lawlexis International’s Career Training for Lawyers series, running since 2018. This year’s theme, “The Lawyer in the Creative Economy,” focuses on the legal frameworks shaping Nigeria’s fastest-growing industries: music, film, fashion, art, gaming, and sports.
Who Will Be Teaching?
CTL 2026 brings together a faculty of practitioners with direct, hands-on experience in the creative economy, including:
Yemisi Falaye (Temple Management) — Music Law
Omotayo Inakoju (Head of Legal, EbonyLife Group) — Film and Media Law
Maleek Oyiza — Gaming and Esports Law
Bernice Asein — Fashion Law
Abiodun Sonaike — Sports Law
Adedunmade Onibokun — Art Law
This is a lineup drawn from lawyers actively working inside the industries they’ll be teaching about — not just commenting on them from the outside.
Do I Have to Be in Lagos?
No. CTL 2026 is fully hybrid. You can attend physically at NECA House, Hakeem Balogun Street, Alausa, Ikeja, Lagos, or join the entire training virtually via Zoom — from anywhere, including outside Nigeria. We’ve already had lawyers registering from Ghana for the virtual session.
What Does It Cost?
Physical attendance: ₦135,000 (Early Bird ₦100,000)
Virtual attendance: ₦85,000 (Early Bird ₦60,000)
Early Bird pricing is available now and ends 30 September 2026. After that, standard pricing applies.
Is There a Discount for Groups?
Yes. If your organisation is sending 3 or more people, you get a 10% discount on registration. This applies whether you’re registering for physical or virtual attendance.
How Do I Pay?
You can register and pay directly online, or transfer to our account:
Fidelity Bank, Account 4011176564 — Account name: Lawlexis
What Will I Actually Learn?
Six modules, each addressing the practical legal issues lawyers are increasingly being asked to navigate:
Music Law — recording and distribution deals, royalties, sampling disputes, streaming contracts
Film Law — production financing, distribution and streaming licensing, co-production structures, IP protection
Fashion Law — trademark protection, design piracy, licensing and manufacturing agreements
Art Law — provenance, authentication, auction and sales agreements, artist rights
Gaming Law — esports contracts, in-game IP, streaming and sponsorship deals
Sports Law — player contracts, endorsement deals, sponsorship agreements
What Happens After I Register?
Once registered, you’ll receive confirmation details, including your access instructions for the physical venue or the Zoom link for virtual attendance closer to the event date. You’ll also receive a Lawlexis International certificate of attendance upon completion.
When Is It Happening?
📅 28–29 October 2026
Register Now
https://selar.com/11h84v18ag
Early Bird pricing ends 30 September 2026 — register now to lock in the lower rate.Questions? Reach us at lawlexisinternational@gmail.com or @lawlexisng.
by Legalnaija | Sep 1, 2026 | Blawg

Africa’s content industry is having a moment. Nigerian films are landing global distribution deals. Streaming platforms are investing directly in local production. International studios are actively seeking African stories and African talent. But behind every one of these deals sits a lawyer who understands not just contract law, but the specific mechanics of how content gets financed, produced, licensed, and distributed across borders.
Omotayo Inakoju is one of those lawyers — and she’s joining CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy to teach the Film and Media Law module.
A Career Built Inside the Industry
Omotayo is an Entertainment and Film Lawyer with over a decade of hands-on experience advising, structuring, and negotiating for the African entertainment ecosystem. She currently serves as Head of Legal at EbonyLife Group, one of Africa’s most prominent media companies, where she leads legal strategy across film, television, and streaming projects.
In this role, she works directly with global studios and distributors — including Netflix, BBC Studios, Sony Pictures, FilmOne Entertainment, and Genesis Group — giving her a front-row view of how content distribution actually works in the digital age, not just how it’s described in textbooks.
Before joining EbonyLife, Omotayo began her career at Silverbird Communications, one of Nigeria’s pioneering television and media brands. There, she managed high-value partnerships, broadcast transactions, and cross-border collaborations — experience that laid the foundation for her deep understanding of media operations, regulatory compliance, and content exploitation at scale.

What She Brings to the Table
Across her career, Omotayo has distinguished herself through:
Strategic legal advisory for international and local film studios, streamers, producers, and talent
Drafting and negotiating complex film, broadcasting, and licensing agreements essential to modern content production and distribution
Guiding companies through compliance requirements spanning media, data, copyright, and digital distribution in an increasingly tech-driven ecosystem
Representing production companies and talent in high-stakes negotiations to close co-production, streaming, and financing deals
This is the kind of experience that can’t be taught from a textbook — it comes from sitting across the table during real negotiations with real global players, and understanding what actually moves a deal forward or breaks it.
A Vision for Africa’s Creative Economy
Omotayo is deeply invested in the future of Africa’s creative economy. She advocates for stronger legal and infrastructural frameworks to help African content compete globally — from IP management to distribution systems. Her conviction is straightforward: with the right legal structures in place, content can become one of the next major economic engines for African nations.
That perspective is exactly what CTL 2026 is designed to pass on to the next generation of lawyers serving this space.
What This Means for CTL 2026
At CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy, Omotayo will lead the Film and Media Law module — walking participants through the practical realities of structuring, negotiating, and protecting content deals in a rapidly evolving industry. This isn’t a theoretical overview; it’s a masterclass from someone who does this work daily, at the highest levels of the industry.
Whether you’re advising a producer on their first co-production deal, helping a studio navigate streaming licensing, or simply trying to understand how Nigeria’s film industry actually does business, this module is built to give you real, applicable expertise.

Register for CTL 2026: The Lawyer in the Creative Economy
Omotayo Inakoju is one of several leading practitioners teaching across six modules this October — Music Law, Film Law, Fashion Law, Art Law, Gaming Law, and Sports Law.
📅 Dates: 28–29 October 2026
📍 Venue: NECA House, Hakeem Balogun Street, Alausa, Ikeja, Lagos
💻 Format: Hybrid — attend physically or join via Zoom
Pricing:
Physical: ₦135,000 (Early Bird ₦100,000)
Virtual: ₦85,000 (Early Bird ₦60,000)
Group discount: 10% off for 3 or more registrations from one organisation
Early Bird pricing ends 30 September 2026.
👉 Register now:
https://selar.com/11h84v18ag
For enquiries, reach us at lawlexisinternational@gmail.com or @lawlexisng.
by Legalnaija | Aug 19, 2026 | Blawg

The numbers are impossible to ignore. Nigeria’s music exports are worth hundreds of millions of dollars annually. Nollywood is the second largest film industry in the world by volume. Nigerian athletes are signing endorsement deals worth tens of millions of naira. The fashion, gaming and art sectors are generating significant economic activity, attracting foreign investment and spawning entirely new categories of dispute, transaction and regulation.
And yet, most Nigerian lawyers have had no formal training in the legal frameworks that govern any of it.
That gap is exactly what Lawlexis International’s 2026 Career Training for Lawyers is designed to close.
What is the Creative Economy?
The creative economy encompasses industries whose value derives primarily from intellectual creativity and cultural output — music, film, fashion, visual art, gaming, sports, and increasingly, the digital ecosystems surrounding them. In Nigeria, these industries are not niche interests. They are mainstream economic drivers, generating employment, foreign exchange, and increasingly, high-stakes legal work.
From the Afrobeats artiste negotiating a global distribution deal, to the fashion label protecting its designs from counterfeit markets, to the esports company navigating Nigeria’s gaming regulation landscape — every actor in the creative economy eventually needs a lawyer. The question is whether that lawyer understands the terrain.
What the 2026 Training Covers
This year’s edition of the Career Training for Lawyers series — themed The Lawyer in the Creative Economy — runs across six modules, each designed to give practitioners both the theoretical framework and the practical deal-making knowledge they need:
Music Law unpacks the architecture of the Nigerian and global music business: how recording, publishing and distribution agreements are structured; how royalties flow through collective management organisations; what streaming economics mean for rights holders; and how disputes over sampling and copyright are resolved.
Film & Television Law takes practitioners inside the Nollywood-streaming economy — covering production and co-production agreements, chain of title, talent contracts, and what it means to license content to Netflix, Prime or Showmax.
Fashion Law addresses a sector that is often overlooked in legal training but is growing rapidly: trademark and design protection for fashion brands, how licensing and collaboration agreements work, and the increasingly complex world of influencer and brand ambassador contracts.
Art Law covers the full lifecycle of a work of art from a legal perspective — artist-gallery relationships, auction and authentication issues, resale rights, cultural property and restitution, and the emerging legal questions around NFTs and digital art.
Gaming & Esports Law introduces practitioners to one of the fastest-growing sectors in Africa: game development and publishing agreements, IP in game assets, esports player contracts, and how Nigeria’s legal framework treats the line between gaming and gambling.
Sports Law addresses athlete representation, image rights, endorsement structuring, sports arbitration, club governance and the intersection of sports and media rights.
Running through all six modules are three cross-cutting themes that touch every part of the creative economy: artificial intelligence and creative works, financing and tax incentives for creative ventures, and data protection for fan and customer-facing platforms.
Who Should Attend
The training is open to lawyers at all levels — from young practitioners building their practice areas to partners seeking to expand their firm’s offering. It is equally valuable for in-house counsel at creative companies, legal officers at media and entertainment organisations, and anyone who advises clients in the creative industries.
Practical Details
The training holds on Wednesday 28th and Thursday 29th October, 2026, running from 9:00am to 5:00pm daily. It is hybrid — attendees can join physically at NECA House, Hakeem Balogun Street, Alausa, Ikeja, Lagos, or virtually via Zoom.
Registration fees are ₦135,000 for physical attendance and ₦85,000 for virtual. Early bird rates of ₦100,000 (physical) and ₦60,000 (virtual) are available until 30th September, 2026. Firms registering three or more participants from the same organisation receive a 10% group discount.
Register here:
https://selar.com/11h84v18ag
For enquiries, contact Lawlexis International at lawlexisinternational@gmail.com or 09029755663.
Lawlexis International has been building the capacity of Nigerian lawyers since 2018 through the Career Training for Lawyers series. Past editions have covered Legal Advocacy, African Trade Law, Tech Law, Corporate Law, and Entertainment & Sports Law.
by Legalnaija | Aug 17, 2026 | Blawg

Unlock Your Practice Growth with Legalnaija Subscriptions
Choose the right plan to elevate your legal practice, enhance client visibility, and access essential resources tailored for legal professionals.
Subscription Tiers & Pricing
| Plan Title |
Cost |
Duration |
Template Access
|
| Basic / Standard Subscription |
₦5,000 |
30 days |
Access to 10 document templates |
| Basic / Standard Yearly Subscription |
₦50,000 |
1 year |
Access to 10 document templates |
| Priority Monthly Listing |
₦3,000 |
30 days |
Full access |
| Priority Yearly Listing |
₦30,000 |
1 year |
Full access |
Plan Benefits Breakdown
- Basic Subscriptions (Monthly & Yearly): Ideal for professionals seeking essential resources, granting access to a curated selection of 10 document templates.
- Priority Listings (Monthly & Yearly): Designed for maximum visibility and comprehensive utility, giving you full, unrestricted access to document templates and priority directory placement.
Need Help Registering?
If you encounter any trouble during the registration process, please feel free to reach out to our team at @legalnaija, call us at 09029755663, or send an email to hello@legalnaija.com for assistance.
Get Started Today
Head over to Legalnaija.com to select the plan that fits your practice goals and start connecting with clients instantly.
by Legalnaija | Aug 14, 2026 | Blawg
Introduction
When you think of “Champagne,” it isn’t just sparkling wine that comes to mind—it’s a region in France, a centuries-old tradition, and a multi-billion dollar reputation. Now imagine the same potential for “Ofada Rice,” “Ijebu Garri,” or “Kilishi.” In a world where products are increasingly associated with the identity of place, Geographical Indications (GIs) have become one of the most powerful, yet underutilized, tools in the intellectual property (IP) arsenal—particularly for countries rich in cultural and agricultural heritage. Despite being a signatory to the TRIPS Agreement[1], which outlines the minimum standards for GI protection, Nigeria lacks a comprehensive domestic legal framework to identify, register, or enforce GIs. This legislative vacuum does not just reflect a gap in law; it reflects a gap in national strategy—one that threatens our economic leverage, cultural sovereignty, and international IP credibility. This article explores the role of GIs within the broader IP ecosystem, Nigeria’s current legal posture, and the socio-economic opportunities we risk losing by not protecting our locally-rooted innovations. It also proposes a policy rethink—either the creation of a standalone GI law or the strategic integration of GI protections into Nigeria’s existing IP infrastructure.
What Are GIs & How Do They Differ from Other IP Rights
Geographical Indications (GIs) are a form of intellectual property protection that links the quality, reputation, or other characteristics of a product to its geographical origin. Unlike trademarks, which are tied to a particular business or entity, GIs belong to a community or region—they signify the collective identity of a product rooted in place. In practical terms, a GI protects not just a name, but the cultural story and environmental uniqueness of that product. The most famous examples are global symbols: Champagne (France), Roquefort cheese (France), Darjeeling tea (India), and Tequila (Mexico). What unites these products is that their commercial and reputational value stems from where and how they’re made. And legally, that origin is enforceable. In contrast, trademarks are source-identifiers for goods or services—used to distinguish one brand from another. A trademark can be owned, sold, licensed, or transferred. Patents, on the other hand, protect inventions and grant exclusive rights to the inventor for a fixed period. Copyright safeguards original works of authorship such as literature, art, or music. All these categories of IP focus on individual ownership, while GIs are inherently collective and location-based. Where GIs shine is in their power to preserve traditional knowledge, boost local economies, and prevent cultural appropriation. For instance, the global popularity of Moroccan Argan oil is safeguarded through GI recognition, ensuring only oil from designated Moroccan regions can use the name. Nigeria, with its own array of unique, origin-based products—from Nsukka yellow pepper to Aso Oke fabric—remains conspicuously silent in the GI arena, both legally and commercially.
Nigeria’s Lack of Legal Framework for GIs
Nigeria’s intellectual property system is primarily governed by three main legal instruments: the Trademarks Act, Patents and Designs Act, and the Copyright Act. Each provides specific protections for different forms of creativity and innovation. Yet, conspicuously missing from this legal framework is any dedicated statute or regulatory guideline for the recognition, registration, and protection of Geographical Indications. In practice, GIs in Nigeria are sometimes shoehorned into the trademark system, either as certification marks or collective marks. This workaround, while technically legal, is conceptually inadequate. GIs are not mere marks of origin; they are intrinsically tied to culture, heritage, and environment. Treating them as trademarks strips them of their deeper socio-economic and cultural value. Even more concerning is the fact that despite being a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO) and a signatory to the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) since 1995, Nigeria has yet to fully domesticate the GI-related provisions under Articles 22 to 24 of the Agreement. TRIPS obliges member states to ensure legal means for interested parties to prevent misuse of GIs and to promote fair competition by protecting region-based identifiers. Institutions like the Nigerian Export Promotion Council (NEPC) and Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission (NIPC) have, over the past decade, partnered with international organizations like the EU Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) and WIPO to conduct mapping exercises on Nigeria’s potential GIs[2]. Products such as Ijebu Garri, Nsukka Yellow Pepper, and Fura de Nunu have been spotlighted in reports—yet these remain recommendations, not enforceable designations. Even the National GI Policy Draft released in collaboration with WIPO has stalled in implementation, with no legislative follow-through to date[3]. These efforts, while commendable, reflect the broader Nigerian IP culture: policy without power. The gap is not just legal—it’s strategic. Without a GI law, Nigerian producers are exposed to exploitation, misappropriation, and loss of premium value in international markets. Countries with far less cultural and agricultural depth have harnessed GI protection to build billion-dollar export industries. Nigeria, on the other hand, still exports its cultural gold under generic labels, missing out on the real value chain.
Comparative Case Studies — Nigerian Potentials vs International Models
To truly appreciate what Nigeria is missing, it helps to look outward—to nations that have embedded Geographical Indications into their economic and cultural playbooks. A standout case is India, which enacted the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act in 1999[4]. The country has since registered over 400 GIs, including the globally respected Darjeeling tea, Basmati rice, and Mysore silk. Beyond protecting local producers, these registrations have created export premiums, rural job opportunities, and a global identity for Indian-origin products. Similarly, the European Union has a comprehensive GI regime[5] that links product labeling, origin, and quality. Products like Feta cheese (Greece), Prosciutto di Parma (Italy), and Roquefort cheese (France) command significant global market shares and are legally protected against imitation under EU and international laws. In many of these cases, the GI recognition has directly influenced the global branding of the countries themselves. In stark contrast, Nigeria’s most identity-rich products remain legally undefined. Ofada rice, for instance, is marketed in Lagos restaurants and UK-based African stores alike, but there’s no regulatory clarity on what qualifies as “Ofada.” Without GI protection, any vendor—anywhere—can slap the name on any rice variety, diluting its heritage and misleading consumers. The same applies to Ijebu garri, which is famed for its sharp taste and fine grain. It has no formal recognition as a GI despite its unique processing method and regional legacy. Worse still, global Nigerian food vendors can use the name without sourcing from Ijebu or meeting any quality controls. The name travels, but the value doesn’t. Even Kilishi, the sun-dried, spice-laden beef snack synonymous with Northern Nigeria, has gained international popularity without formal protection. In 2021, Nigerian diaspora communities in Canada and the UK were already seeing knockoff versions labeled “Kilishi-style jerky”—products often produced without traditional methods or ingredients. These examples underscore a painful truth: Nigeria has exported identity, but not ownership. Without a GI regime, our cultural products remain globally exploitable but legally defenceless.
The Economic and Developmental Power of GIs
The conversation around Geographical Indications isn’t just legal—it’s deeply economic. At its core, GI protection allows countries to extract full value from their cultural and natural resources, especially in rural and artisanal economies. This is where Nigeria has the most to gain, and the most to lose.In countries like India and Morocco, GIs have served as powerful tools for poverty reduction, brand elevation, and rural empowerment. For example, following the GI registration of Pochampally Ikat fabric in India, local weavers experienced a sharp rise in both visibility and pricing power, resulting in increased wages and export opportunities. Morocco’s protection of Argan oil under a GI scheme has helped build sustainable livelihoods for thousands of rural women in cooperatives. For Nigeria, the potential is arguably larger. Our cultural exports—from food and spices, to textiles, leatherwork, and traditional beverages—already command loyalty among diasporic and international markets. However, in the absence of GI protections, middlemen and offshore manufacturers often reap the profits, while local producers remain invisible and underpaid. This is especially critical in the context of Nigeria’s long-running dependence on crude oil exports. For decades, national conversations around diversification have focused on agriculture and manufacturing, but without attention to how IP tools can unlock global competitiveness. GIs offer an intangible yet powerful bridge between local production and international trade value. If we protect and brand our unique products, we don’t just sell raw commodities—we sell identity. The African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA)[6] makes this conversation even more urgent. As intra-African trade opens up, countries with protected and branded local goods will gain dominance in cross-border markets. Nigeria risks being a supplier of raw goods, while nations with GI protections become the sellers of finished, branded products. Without a GI framework, we may once again play the role of exporter-without-value. Even from a tourism and national branding perspective, GIs can reinforce identity and pride. Imagine packaging “Ijebu Garri” or “Abakaliki Rice” as global delicacies protected under Nigerian law—much like Parmigiano-Reggiano is protected in Italy. That’s more than semantics; it’s policy-backed positioning on the world stage. From boosting farmer income and job creation, to attracting foreign markets and protecting our narrative, GIs are more than economic instruments—they’re development levers. And yet, the silence in our law books remains deafening.
Conclusion & Legal Recommendations
Nigeria stands at a crucial crossroads in its intellectual property evolution[7]. While we have made modest progress in trademarks, copyright, and patents, the gaping void in GI protection is no longer excusable—it is strategically unsound, economically costly, and culturally negligent. We are a nation of origin-rich products. From the artistry of Akwete cloth to the distinct flavor of Kilishi, we possess what many nations try to fabricate—authenticity. But authenticity without legal protection is exploitation waiting to happen.
To reverse this trajectory, three key interventions are necessary:
- Enactment of a Standalone GI Legislation:
Nigeria must urgently introduce a Geographical Indications (Registration and Protection) Act, similar to India’s model. This legislation should define GIs, set up a national registry, establish quality control frameworks, and empower producers’ cooperatives to own and enforce these rights.
- Strategic Integration with Existing IP Infrastructure:
Pending new legislation, the Trademarks Registry under NIPO should work with stakeholders to create clearer provisions and guidelines for certification and collective marks that function more like GIs. While this is not ideal, it can serve as a legal stopgap.
- National GI Sensitization and Mapping:
There should be deliberate national and regional efforts to educate local producers, identify GI candidates, and standardize quality protocols. These efforts should not just live in WIPO report[8]—they should be funded, legislated, and domestically driven. The time for pilot projects is over. The global IP landscape is not waiting for Nigeria to figure it out. As AfCFTA reshapes trade dynamics, countries that legally protect their local identity will sell it. Others will simply supply it. Geographical Indications are not a luxury—they are a legal necessity for cultural dignity,economic growth, and strategic international competitiveness. The ball is firmly in our court. Whether we choose to legislate or continue to label generically is a question of whether we’re ready to own what we already possess.
[1] Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), April 15, 1994, Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, Annex 1C.
[2] NEPC & WIPO, Identification of Potential Geographical Indications in Nigeria: A Preliminary Report, 2021.
[3] World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), “Geographical Indications: An Introduction,” WIPO Publication No. 952(E), 2020.
[4] Indian Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999 (India).
[5] European Commission, “EU Geographical Indications,” https://ec.europa.eu.
[6] African Union, Agreement Establishing the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), 2018.
[7] Olwan, R. M., Intellectual Property and Development: Theory and Practice, Springer, 2013, pp. 112–120.
[8] Nigerian Export Promotion Council, “Mapping Nigeria’s Unique Products for GI Registration,” https://nepc.gov.ng.
A. E. Alabi, Esq. is an intellectual property lawyer with a keen interest in the intersection of law, innovation, technology, and the creative economy. His work focuses on helping businesses and creators identify, protect, and maximize the value of their intellectual assets while contributing to conversations on emerging issues in copyright, trademarks, artificial intelligence, and regulatory policy. He is passionate about developing practical legal frameworks that strengthen innovation and position intellectual property as a driver of economic growth.
by Legalnaija | Aug 14, 2026 | Blawg
Leadership Forged Through Persistence
Every presidency has a story, but some stories begin long before the oath of office is taken. For Mazi Afam Osigwe, SAN, the journey to the presidency of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) was marked by setbacks and persistence. His presidency, therefore, is best understood not only by what he did in office, but also by the long and difficult road that brought him there.
In 2018, while seeking the office of NBA President, Osigwe was disqualified by the Electoral Committee of the NBA, a decision he vigorously challenged as unlawful and inconsistent with the Association’s Constitution. Rather than retreat from public life, he continued to serve the profession, remained actively engaged in Bar affairs, and six years later emerged victorious, taking the oath of office on 29th August, 2024, as the 32nd President of the NBA. His eventual emergence was, in many respects, a testament to resilience, persistence, and unwavering commitment to the profession.
The Promises of the Osigwe Presidency
At his inauguration, President Osigwe laid out an ambitious vision for the Association. He pledged to defend the rule of law, hold governments accountable, pursue meaningful justice sector reforms, strengthen constitutional democracy, improve lawyers’ welfare, reform the NBA Constitution, ensure prompt issuance of NBA Stamp and Seal, and position the Bar as a fearless voice on issues affecting Nigerians.
It was a manifesto that promised an activist Bar, independent of political influence, and unapologetic in defending constitutional governance.
A Bar That Spoke Truth to Power
Perhaps the defining feature of the Osigwe administration has been its willingness to speak truth to power.
Whether commenting on executive actions, legislative conduct, or judicial performance, the NBA under his leadership consistently projected itself as an independent institutional voice. His criticism of the Senate’s screening of ambassadorial nominees, which he described as falling short of constitutional expectations, reflected a broader insistence that democratic institutions must be subjected to genuine accountability.
The administration repeatedly called on governments at all levels to improve security, respect fundamental rights, deepen transparency, and reduce the cost of governance. On matters affecting constitutional democracy, the NBA maintained a visible and often influential presence.
Unlike many Bar leaders who avoid publicly criticizing the judiciary, Osigwe consistently acknowledged that the justice sector itself requires reform.
His repeated warnings about conflicting judgments, judicial corruption, delayed justice, and declining public confidence generated national debate. His observation that corruption within the judiciary represents one of the greatest threats to constitutional democracy was controversial but resonated with many lawyers who believe meaningful reform cannot occur without confronting uncomfortable realities.
Yet his criticism was accompanied by constructive proposals. The administration advocated comprehensive justice sector reforms, improved judicial welfare, mental health support for judges, better infrastructure, continuing judicial education, and institutional measures designed to restore confidence in the courts.
Defending Human Rights and Standing With the Vulnerable
Human rights advocacy remained another defining hallmark of the administration.
The NBA was vocal about issues involving unlawful arrests, constitutional freedoms, and police accountability. During the prosecution of persons arrested in connection with the “#EndBadGovernance” protests, the Association directed its branches to monitor proceedings nationwide while establishing pro bono legal representation for protesters who were unable to secure counsel.
Similarly, the administration strongly condemned reported mob attacks and sexual violence against women, insisting that cultural practices can never justify violations of human dignity. Such interventions reinforced the NBA’s traditional role as the guardian of civil liberties.
Another notable example of Afam Osigwe’s intervention as President of the NBA was his response to the attempted arraignment of lawyer and activist Gabriel Tsenyen by the Department of State Services (DSS). Osigwe personally showed up in court and ensured that the NBA designated a formidable defence team to represent the lawyer. His intervention demonstrated the NBA’s willingness, under his leadership, to stand up for its members when their professional and constitutional rights come under threat, and underscored the importance of an independent Bar in defending the rule of law.
Beyond public advocacy, the administration pursued reforms directed at the legal profession itself.
One notable achievement was the expansion of Continuing Legal Education through the NBA Institute of Continuing Legal Education. The accreditation of dozens of NBA branches as CLE providers significantly decentralized professional development, reduced costs, and enabled lawyers across Nigeria to earn mandatory Continuing Professional Development points closer to home.
Equally significant was renewed attention to lawyers’ welfare. Through the National Remuneration Committee, the administration sought to establish minimum remuneration standards for legal practitioners and address the longstanding concern that many young lawyers receive wages inconsistent with the dignity of the profession. Although implementation will largely depend on future administrations and employers, the initiative represented one of the boldest institutional efforts in recent years to confront poor remuneration within legal practice.
Expanding the NBA’s Institutional Reach
The administration also focused on rebuilding institutional partnerships.
One notable milestone was the NBA’s renewed partnership with UNICEF for the implementation of a Justice for Children and Young People programme reportedly valued at approximately ₦120 million. Beyond its financial significance, the partnership signalled renewed confidence by international development partners in the institutional capacity of the Nigerian Bar Association.
Likewise, the 2025 Annual General Conference received widespread commendation for its organisation, quality of discourse and participation, reinforcing the NBA Conference as one of Africa’s foremost legal gatherings.
The Uncomfortable Questions and the Other Side of the Record
No presidency is immune from criticism, and the Osigwe administration proved no exception.
One criticism that has emerged in some quarters of the Afam Osigwe administration is that, while the National Executive Committee appeared to function with considerably greater cohesion than its immediate predecessor, the office of the President sometimes seemed to overshadow the other national offices, with the visibility and institutional voice of the NBA becoming heavily concentrated around the President.
Take, for instance, the highly cerebral and innovative National Publicity Secretary, Bridget Ijeoma Edokwe, Esq., publisher of BarristerNG, whom many members of the Bar expected would play a more prominent role in shaping and projecting a progressive public image of the NBA in keeping with the responsibilities of her office. Instead, she remained relatively quiet in the public space, perhaps working diligently behind the scenes. The same could be said of several other accomplished lawyers who were prominent voices within the Bar before assuming national office but became considerably less visible thereafter.
This should not, however, obscure an important strength of the Osigwe administration. Unlike the immediate past National Executive Committee, which was repeatedly embroiled in public disagreements and allegations of constitutional breaches, the current National Executive Committee largely succeeded in presenting a more united front and functioning as a more cohesive team, even if the President’s overwhelming visibility sometimes made the administration appear more presidential than collegiate.
The 2026 Election and the Crisis of Confidence
In addition, as the 2026 NBA elections approached, concerns emerged regarding the credibility of the electoral process. Some lawyers alleged irregularities, questioned aspects of the administration’s neutrality and expressed dissatisfaction with the conduct of the elections.
The sharp decline in voter participation in the 2026 election raised serious questions about the integrity, accessibility and effectiveness of the electoral process. In 2022, Yakubu Maikyau, SAN secured 22,342 votes in an election in which about 43,000 votes were cast. In 2024, Afam Osigwe, SAN secured 20,435 votes out of 40,451 votes cast. In 2026, however, Oyinkansola Badejo Okusanya, SAN emerged with just 12,317 votes, while only 26,184 votes were cast from an eligible voting population of 82,172 lawyers. The decline is therefore striking. Although a lower turnout does not by itself establish electoral malpractice, the scale of the decline, coupled with repeated complaints from lawyers who reportedly attempted but were unable to vote, raises legitimate concerns about disenfranchisement and whether the NBA’s electoral system is adequately designed to guarantee broad and meaningful participation by its members.
President Osigwe, however, consistently rejected allegations that he interfered in the electoral process or compromised the independence of the Electoral Committee of the NBA (ECNBA). He maintained that the ECNBA remained constitutionally independent and repeatedly urged lawyers not to use either the courts or political actors to undermine the Association’s electoral process.
Whether those explanations fully satisfied critics remains a matter of opinion. What is beyond dispute is that the election controversies exposed deep divisions within the Bar that the next administration must address.
A Record That Will Invite Debate
Measured against the promises made upon assuming office, the Osigwe presidency leaves behind a substantial record.
The administration restored the NBA’s visibility in national discourse, strengthened Continuing Legal Education, pursued improvements in lawyers’ welfare, deepened human rights advocacy, promoted judicial reform, defended constitutional governance, and enhanced the Association’s institutional engagement with development partners.
At the same time, the administration will inevitably be remembered for the controversies surrounding the 2026 elections and the broader debates they generated about transparency, neutrality, and institutional trust. While those criticisms remain contested and were firmly denied by the President, they nevertheless form part of the historical record of the administration.
On balance, however, history is likely to remember the Osigwe presidency as one defined more by activism than passivity, more by engagement than silence, and more by institutional ambition than administrative routine.
The Challenge Awaiting the Incoming President
The work of the Nigerian Bar Association remains unfinished.
Afam Osigwe, SAN is expected to hand over the presidency of the NBA to the incoming administration during the 66th NBA Annual General Conference, which is scheduled to take place in Port Harcourt, Rivers State, from August 21 to 28, 2026. The incoming President inherits an Association that is more visible, more vocal, and more influential than it was two years ago. Yet the Bar also appears more polarised, with growing dissatisfaction among segments of the profession regarding welfare, representation, and electoral confidence.
The next administration must therefore move beyond managing the Association to genuinely uniting it. Restoring confidence in the electoral process, implementing meaningful welfare reforms, strengthening institutional transparency, and ensuring that every lawyer, regardless of geography, seniority or professional status, feels represented should become defining priorities.
Ultimately, the enduring strength of the NBA will not be measured solely by the courage of one President, but by the collective determination of successive leaders to preserve its independence and integrity, promote the rule of law, fight for justice, protect human rights, and build a Bar that truly speaks for and serves every Nigerian lawyer.
Henry Chibuike Ugwu, LL.B, LL.M, J.D, B.L
Attorney at Law, Florida | Barrister and Solicitor of the Supreme Court of Nigeria
henrycugwu@gmail.com
by Legalnaija | Aug 14, 2026 | Blawg

On Thursday, 9 July 2026, I attended the Call to Bar Ceremony at the Body of Benchers Complex, Abuja, as a special guest, following an invitation from my Principal during my externship. I went expecting to witness one of the most solemn rites of passage in the Nigerian legal profession. I left with something more: admiration for the profession I hope to join, but also questions about what we mean when we describe law as a “sober profession.”
The July 2026 Call to Bar was significant. The four-day ceremony ran from 7 to 10 July 2026, with 6,009 successful candidates admitted into the Nigerian Bar. For those candidates, it represented the end of an arduous journey through university and the Nigerian Law School and the beginning of a much greater professional responsibility.¹
For me, however, being there had a deeply personal significance. As I watched successful candidates take the final step into the profession, I could not escape the feeling that my presence was more than coincidence. It felt like an affirmation, a glimpse of a promise that, with diligence, character and perseverance, I too would one day take my place at the Nigerian Bar.
Yet, amid that sense of fulfilment, something troubled me.
The Haircut That Raised a Larger Question
At the ceremony, I witnessed male aspirants who, to my eyes, were properly dressed, neat and already wearing low, groomed haircuts being required to return and cut their hair even lower.
That experience presented what I consider a genuine ethical dilemma.
There is no dispute that the legal profession is entitled to prescribe standards of appearance. Indeed, professional discipline is part of what distinguishes the Bar. Rule 1 of the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners 2023 (“RPC”) requires a lawyer to uphold and observe the rule of law, promote and foster the cause of justice, maintain a high standard of professional conduct and refrain from conduct unbecoming of a legal practitioner.
Rule 36 goes further in relation to appearance in court. It requires a lawyer to be attired in a proper and dignified manner and prohibits apparel or ornaments calculated to attract attention to the lawyer. It also requires observance of the customs of the Bar concerning appearance, dress, manners and courtesy.
These are sensible requirements. A courtroom is not a fashion runway. Neither is the legal profession an avenue for personal display at the expense of the solemn administration of justice.
But Rule 36 does not prescribe the number of centimetres of hair that constitutes dignity.
It does not say that an Afro is inherently inconsistent with professional sobriety.
And therein lies the dilemma.
Call-to-Bar guidelines have gone beyond the general language of the RPC. For example, guidelines issued by the Body of Benchers for the November 2025 Call to Bar required male aspirants to maintain a “neat low haircut”. Female aspirants were required to maintain natural hair and were prohibited from coloured hair, attachments, artificial nails, nail polish, artificial eyelashes and heavy makeup.²
The rationale is evidently decorum. But my experience caused me to ask a deceptively simple question: how low is low enough?
If a Nigerian man has bathed, wears freshly washed and ironed prescribed clothing, maintains clean natural nails, has no distracting accessories and presents his naturally textured African hair neatly trimmed and combed, what precisely makes him insufficiently sober?
More importantly, if he already has what would ordinarily be regarded as a neat low haircut, what additional ethical value is achieved by requiring him to cut it lower?
This is not an argument against dress codes. Nor is it an accusation that requiring neat hair is inherently discriminatory. Professional institutions must be able to maintain standards.
It is instead an argument for proportionality.
The ethical objective should be professional dignity, not uniformity merely for uniformity’s sake.
There is something worth interrogating when, in Nigeria, an African preparing to enter what has been described as the largest Bar in Africa can present his natural hair neatly and conservatively yet still feel that its natural texture or volume must be further suppressed before his appearance sufficiently reflects professional sobriety.
Our profession inherited many of its traditions from England: the wig, gown, forms of address, courtroom etiquette and other conventions. Tradition has value. It gives the profession continuity and institutional identity.
But tradition should not become immune from examination simply because it is tradition.
The history of the Nigerian Bar itself demonstrates that professional conventions can evolve. Following the controversy surrounding Amasa Firdaus Abdulsalam, who was denied participation in a 2017 Call to Bar ceremony after refusing to remove her hijab, the Body of Benchers subsequently permitted the wearing of the hijab for law-related activities.³
The profession survived that accommodation. Its dignity did not disappear.
That episode demonstrates an important point: professional dignity and individual identity are not necessarily enemies.
Can a Sober Profession Celebrate?
Another lesson from the ceremony concerned the use of legal regalia.
Immediately before the July 2026 Call, the Council of Legal Education issued a warning against candidates wearing wigs and gowns and presenting themselves on social media as qualified legal practitioners before they had formally been called. The Council specifically criticised candidates who described themselves prematurely as “Barristers and Solicitors of the Supreme Court” or appended “Esquire” to their names. It warned that such conduct could attract disciplinary consequences and affect eligibility for Call to Bar.⁴
The Council was on firmer ethical ground here.
Aspirants may understandably be excited, but professional status cannot be assumed before it is legally acquired. Section 22 of the Legal Practitioners Act regulates unauthorised practice, while Rule 45 RPC regulates the use of lawyers’ robes outside court. The distinction between almost a lawyer and a lawyer may appear small to an excited aspirant, but ethically and legally it is fundamental.
I also learned at the ceremony that “Barrister” is not properly used as a prefix or title before a lawyer’s name. The Chairman of the Body of Benchers, Chief Albert Akpomudje, SAN, CFR, cautioned the newly admitted lawyers against the practice during the July 2026 ceremony.⁵
These lessons reinforced something important: the wig and gown are not costumes.
They represent an office and a professional responsibility.
But a related question remains.
Should sobriety eliminate celebration?
Consider what precedes Call to Bar.
For some, the journey began with unsuccessful attempts to obtain admission to study law. Others experienced financial difficulties, family challenges or personal circumstances that interrupted their education. Some completed university but could not immediately proceed to the Nigerian Law School. Others watched their classmates proceed while they waited.
Then comes Law School itself.
Candidates study under enormous pressure knowing that an adverse result can delay the dream they have pursued for years. Some watch friends return for resit examinations. Others eventually arrive at Call after a journey considerably longer and more difficult than they imagined when they first opened a law textbook.
Then, finally, their names appear among those eligible to be called.
After all that, must celebrating in a red suit or brown corporate attire for a private photograph necessarily be inconsistent with belonging to a “sober profession”?
I do not think the answer should automatically be yes.
There is an important distinction between wearing legal regalia improperly or falsely representing oneself as a lawyer, on the one hand, and celebrating an extraordinary personal achievement after legitimately attaining it, on the other.
Sobriety should describe the lawyer’s character and professional conduct, not the complete absence of colour or joy from the lawyer’s life.
What the Ceremony Taught Me
My greatest lesson from the 2026 Call to Bar was that becoming a lawyer is a fragile and intentional journey.
An aspirant may spend years preparing for the profession and still discover, at the final threshold, that seemingly minor conduct can have professional consequences. The Council of Legal Education’s July 2026 warning made this particularly clear: premature use of professional regalia or representations of professional status could jeopardise eligibility for Call.⁶
I therefore learned that legal ethics does not begin with one’s first client.
It does not begin with one’s first court appearance.
It begins with understanding that admission into the profession carries an identity that must neither be falsely assumed nor carelessly represented.
I also witnessed the extraordinary importance the profession attaches to hierarchy and institutional respect. The Chairman’s presence and leave were formally recognised before steps were taken. To an outsider, some of these practices may appear ceremonial. To someone preparing for the profession, they communicate something deeper: the Bar expects humility.
But the same profession that teaches us respect for rules also teaches us to interrogate them.
Lawyers ask: What is the rule? What is its purpose? Is its application consistent with that purpose? Does the distinction being drawn have a rational basis? Does the result advance justice?
We should be capable of respectfully asking the same questions about our professional traditions.
The Bar I Hope to Join
I do not want a Nigerian Bar without standards.
I want to join a profession that takes appearance seriously, insists on discipline, protects the significance of its regalia and demands exemplary conduct from those privileged to practise law.
But I equally hope to join a profession confident enough in its identity to distinguish dignity from rigidity, sobriety from sameness, and professional regulation from unnecessary restriction.
Natural African hair that is clean, trimmed, combed and professionally maintained is not inherently rebellious. Clean natural nails are not unprofessional. Tasteful celebration is not necessarily incompatible with professional restraint.
The real ethical inquiry should always return to the purpose behind the standard: does the conduct genuinely undermine the dignity of the profession?
If it does, the profession is justified in regulating it.
If it does not, perhaps the tradition deserves another look.
As I watched 6,009 people cross the threshold into the Nigerian Bar that week, I saw something of my future in them. Their Call reminded me that the privilege of becoming a lawyer carries responsibilities long before one’s first brief is received.
It also reminded me of the kind of lawyer I hope to become: one who respects the traditions of the profession without believing that respect requires intellectual silence.
The legal profession is, indeed, a sober profession. But sobriety should ultimately mean integrity, discipline, restraint, responsibility and service to justice. It should never become a convenient synonym for unnecessary rigidity.
I left the Body of Benchers Complex that Thursday with admiration, questions and hope.
And perhaps that is precisely what legal education should produce.
For me, the ceremony was more than an externship experience. It felt like an affirmation and a promise yet to be fulfilled.
I am next in turn to be called to the Bar.
And when that day comes, I hope to enter a profession whose traditions I understand, whose dignity I will protect, and whose continued development I will never be afraid to thoughtfully question.
References
- The Guardian, ‘Guardian Law Editor Onyekwere, Mokuolu, among 6,009 new lawyers called to Bar’ (9 July 2026).
- Body of Benchers, Guidelines for the November 2025 Call to Bar Ceremony, as reported by BarristerNG, 19 November 2025.
- The Guardian, ‘Body of Benchers okays use of hijab for law activities’ (22 June 2018).
- Council of Legal Education, Public Notice on unauthorised use of barristers’ regalia by candidates awaiting Call to Bar, as reported by Punch, 7 July 2026.
- Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners 2023, rr 1, 36 and 45; Legal Practitioners Act, Cap L11 LFN 2004, s 22.
- Council of Legal Education, Public Notice, July 2026.
Author’s Bio
CHIKAMADU BEULAH JAMES is a Nigerian Law School student and emerging legal writer with interests in legal ethics, professional responsibility, human rights and the development of the Nigerian legal profession. Her writing explores the relationship between law, professional culture and contemporary social realities.The views expressed in this article are the author’s personal reflections.
by Legalnaija | Aug 14, 2026 | Blawg
The Proper Constitution of a Shari’a Court: Whether It Suffices for One Judge to Sit Alone or with Two Other Members:The Supreme Court case of Katsayel v. Abdullahi (2026) 12 NWLR (Pt. 2053) 1.
The facts of this case orbits around an inheritance dispute, something many families can relate to. It involves sisters and their brother. The dispute traces its historical paternity to the year 2006. Upon the demise of their father called Abdullahi, wherein he left five children, four daughters and one male, with what appeared to be a straightforward inheritance, as there were four farmlands and a house. Among the children were Hafsatu and Sa’ida, and their younger brother, Auwalu Abdullahi.
The sisters, more specifically the two mentioned above, maintained that all four farmlands and the house formed part of their late father’s estate and ought to be distributed among them in accordance with Islamic law. Their younger brother, though, agreed, but partially, as according to him, it’s the house and two farmlands that belonged to their late father, the remaining two farmlands belonged exclusively to him, having been gifted to him by their father during his lifetime.
That assertion however, changed everything. These two sisters vehemently rejected the claim. They were like, “How can that be possible? Why are we not aware of the gift? Shouldn’t our father have told us at least about it? How can we now believe you? And in a bid to ensure everything was distributed in due fidelity with Islamic law of inheritance principles, they consequently instituted an action before the Shari’a Court, Katsina State, seeking the distribution of all the inherited properties.
Trial began on 7th July, 2006.Throughout the proceedings, Auwalu, their brother, stood firmly like Aso Rock, by his story. He insisted that the two disputed farmlands were validly gifted to him before their father’s demise. Evidence and witnesses were tendered and called by both the feuding parties. The trial court judge even took the extra effort to visit the farmlands and the house, something which in law we call “Locus in quo”, where the judge pays a visit to the disputed property, especially in land matters. After carefully evaluating the evidence, at the end of the day, however, the court found that the alleged gift was never established by credible evidence. It is an elementary position of the law under the common law that needs no citation of a section or a case that he who asserts must prove. That applies mutatis mutandis even under Islamic law. What happens where a person fails to prove a claim? Certainly, he has himself to blame, as judgment will not be in his favour, unfortunately, that’s certainly what happened. He was unable to prove the gift, therefore on 23rd August, 2006, the Shari’a Court held that all four farmlands and the house formed part of the deceased’s estate ditto ordered that they be distributed among all the heirs accordingly.
Expectedly, the sisters left the courtroom with smiles on their faces, and what do you expect? Of course they would. They had succeeded. It was actually worth being happy about. Two lands are huge, imagine the distribution without them.
Auwalu certainly was not happy. I don’t expect him to be. I am sure you wouldn’t either. According to him, the trial court had erred, and instead of disobeying the sacred judgment, he did what every litigant aggrieved with the decision of a court is expected to do, which is appeal. He appealed to the Upper Shari’a Court, Daura. On 11th June, 2007, the Upper Shari’a Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decision of the trial court. Still dissatisfied, he proceeded to the Shari’a Court of Appeal, Katsina State. Once again, fortune refused to smile on him.
On 21st August, 2007, the Shari’a Court of Appeal equally dismissed his appeal consequently affirmed the concurrent decisions of the two lower courts, hook, line, and sinker.
At this point, one would naturally think the matter had finally come to an end. Three courts against you? Of course you will feel like giving up. They are three different courts speaking with one voice.
But litigation, as lawyers often say, is full of surprises. Auwalu refused to give up. He approached the Court of Appeal, Kaduna Division. Now, this is where the case assumed an entirely different dimension.
Interestingly, the Court of Appeal did not concern itself with whether the alleged gift was proved or not. Rather, it noticed something much more fundamental. Jurisdiction, the heartbeat and lifeblood of every court; in the absence of it, the court will be lifeless.
The court observed that section 4(1) of the Shari’a Court Law of Katsina State, 2000, provides that: “A Shari’a Court shall properly be constituted if presided over by an Alkali [Judge] sitting with two members.”
It’s upon a panoramic examination of this Almighty provision catalogued supra, vis-à-vis a due consultation with the spinal cord of the appeal, that’s the record of proceedings, the Court of Appeal found that although all three members appeared during the first sitting, the subsequent proceedings and judgment did not sufficiently show that the complete panel sat throughout the hearing. Put bluntly, the record of proceedings showed that at the first sitting, as required by section 4(1), the Alkali and two others sat, but in subsequent sittings till judgment, it was only the Alkali that continued to sit. This finding changed everything. On 24th September, 2020, the Court of Appeal, without an atom of doubt, nullified the hitherto entire proceedings. Put differently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the judgments of the three lower courts, and ordered that the matter be tried “denovo” (afresh) before the Upper Shari’a Court.
Imagine the disappointment of the sisters. After successfully defending the case before three different courts, they suddenly found themselves back to square one. Should they abide by that? Certainly, you don’t expect them to, after all, there’s still a more superior court, the Supreme Court, the last hope of the common man, they call it, so they opted to approach the Supreme Court rather than going back, hoping to restore the judgments earlier delivered in their favour by the three courts.
This is where the appeal became particularly interesting. Nota bene, the sisters are now the appellants, and their brother is the respondent. The appellants, in a bid to abort the appeal in limine, argued that the two members contemplated under section 4(1) merely assisted the Alkali and did not function as judges. Consequently, according to them, the absence of their presence, assuming they were absent, or their signatures or endorsements on the judgment, could not invalidate the proceedings.At first glance, the argument sounded persuasive.
But can the argument safe the said suit of nearly twenty (20) years from being sent back to square one?
The Supreme Court, per Ibrahim Mohammed Musa Saulawa, J.S.C., who delivered the leading judgment, started by reiterating the ageless settled principle in Madukolu v. Nkemdilim that before any court can validly exercise jurisdiction, it must first be properly constituted in terms of both the qualification and the number of persons required by law.
The court held that the language of section 4(1) is plain and admits of no ambiguity.
The law requires an Alkali sitting with two members.
Nothing in the provision suggests that the two members are optional or that they merely serve as assessors. The Supreme Court further emphasized that courts are not permitted to import words into a statute which the legislature deliberately omitted. After all, courts are not legislatures and, as such, cannot smuggle a word that’s not ab initio there. They are just to interpret the existing words. Accordingly, since the record failed to establish that the complete statutory quorum sat throughout the proceedings, the trial court lacked the competence to adjudicate the matter. Without jurisdiction, everything done thereafter collapsed like a house built on a faulty foundation. The appeal therefore failed in toto. The judgment of the Court of Appeal ordering a retrial was firma terra in law and was therefore accorded an undiluted affirmation for not disclosing any ounce of hostility that would magnet or warrant the reprobation of the Supreme Court.
All the other Justices, M. L. Garba, J.S.C., the presiding Justice, Tukur, J.S.C., Idris, J.S.C., concurred and adopted the same reasoning, except Abiru, J.S.C.
Without prejudice, it is said that most often the finest Justices dissented. So the story did not end there. Abiru, J.S.C., delivered a powerful dissenting opinion. His Lordship, while citing legion of judicial authorities, lucidly evinced that appellate courts dealing with proceedings from Shari’a Courts ought to focus more on substance than technical form. They are not courts of record like the High Court. As such, there shouldn’t be expectation of strict adhering to strict procedure or technical rules. His Lordship painstakingly, with his prey eagle judicial eye, examined both the Hausa and English versions of the record and concluded that the proceedings substantially showed the participation of the two members throughout the hearing. In his view, the omission complained of was insufficient to invalidate proceedings that had otherwise achieved substantial justice, and accordingly he set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal and affirmed that of the three courts. However, in the eyes of the law, or in the light of the doctrine of stare decisis, the net effect of my Lord’s dissenting view is that, it is not law, as it goes with no binding effect, because just as in any deliberative body, the majority have it. In the instant case, the decision was by a majority of four Justices against one.
In the light of the above lucid juridical survey, it’s apropos to conclude that had His Lordship’s opinion commanded the majority, the litigation would have ended there and then.
Unfortunately for the sisters, it did not. Nearly twenty (20) years after the dispute first arose in 2006, the parties were once again back where they started, probably preparing for another trial. Lastly, this decision once again reminds us that jurisdiction remains the lifeblood of every judicial proceeding. A court may painstakingly evaluate evidence, correctly apply the law, and even reach the right conclusion. Yet, where it lacks the legal competence to sit, every effort becomes legally worthless. Whether one agrees with the majority or finds the dissenting view of Abiru, J.S.C., more appealing, one lesson remains constant: once the law prescribes how a thing should be done, that requirement is not a mere “technicality.” Take them lightly at your own peril, as it may later cost you a lot specifically if it borders on issue of jurisdiction; Jurisdiction the very foundation upon which the entire proceedings stand. And on this, I say no more.
______________________________________________
Isah Bala Garba is a Level 400 student of Common and Islamic Law and a Senior Advocate of Bayero University, Kano,(SABUK).He has authored numerous legal articles and analyzed many cases in clear, plain language. He can be reached for comments or corrections on: LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/isah-bala-garba-301983276 isahbalagarba05@gmail.com or on 08100129131.