FEASIBILITY OF LEGAL PROTECTION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY IN SPACE

FEASIBILITY OF LEGAL PROTECTION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY IN SPACE

 

INTRODUCTION

Space law according to Britannica is the body of regulations in international law that governs conduct in and related to areas of space above Earth’s lower atmosphere. This law addresses a variety of matters, such as, for example, the preservation of the space and Earth environment, liability for damages caused by space objects, the settlement of disputes, the rescue of astronauts, the sharing of information about potential dangers in outer space, the use of space-related technologies, and international cooperation.                                           Space exploration began in October 1957 when Russia launched its unmanned satellite. The evolution of space law began with U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower’s introduction of the concept into the United Nations in 1957, in connection with disarmament negotiations. Following the successful launchings of the Soviet satellite Sputnik 1 in 1957 and the U.S. satellite Explorer 1 in 1958, both the United States and the U.S.S.R. took an active interest in the development of international space policy.

LEGAL STATUS OF AN OUTER SPACE

At the beginning of Space Age in 1957, discussions began in the State community, within the UN, precisely on the legal status of this new issue. Several legal concepts of traditional public international law could be applied to a newly ‘discovered’ area. At final, the approach, which was chosen by the State community, was quite different from but comparable with the regime established for the high sea, where no State sovereignty is accepted. An outer Space was declared as a res communis which is not subject to the sovereignty of any State, and where States are bound to refrain themselves from any acts that can adversely affect the use of an outer space by the other states.

 

LEGAL REGULATIONS OF ACTIVITIES IN SPACE

On 4 October 1957, the Space Age actually began when the world’s first artificial satellite, SPUTNIK-1 (`travelling companion’) was launched by the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR). Subsequently, other suggestions have also been made in relevance to the matter, which, if not juridical, undoubtedly possess the merits of expediency, what does it mean?

1) Quite a number of interests of the States in an exploration and use of outer space, for instance, considerations on policy and strategy in regards to science and economics. This is so in order to avoid confusion and conflicts as well as to enable some orderly procedures on special required rules.

2) Outlining the basic principles for further evolution in law with a tendency to allow the situation to get out of hand and then crystallize in various shape and forms, thus a detriment to a cohesion and an uniformity. While the circumstances surrounding the proper place for space law within the context of international law have been in a debate, a prompt search for analogies and models will be in the older structures within that sphere.

 

LEGAL FEASIBILITY, WHAT IS?

Legal feasibility is the study to know if the proposed project conform the legal and ethical requirements. It is important that the project or business is following the requirements needed to start a business or a project including business licenses, certificates, copyrights, business insurance, tax number, etc.  There are some things to consider in legal feasibility study including ethical issues and some social issues. These issues are the privacy, nepotism, and accountability. It determines whether the proposed system conflicts with legal requirements, e.g., a data processing system must comply with the local data protection regulations and if the proposed venture is acceptable in accordance to the laws of the land.

 

RATIONALE OF THE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Intellectual property (IP) according to WIPO refers to creations of the mind, such as inventions; literary and artistic works; designs; and symbols, names and images used in commerce. IP is protected in law by, for example, patents, copyright and trademarks,

  1. I) Copyrights is a legal term used to portray and examine the rights that creators have over their literary and artistic works. Works covered by copyright range from books, music, paintings, sculpture and films, to computer programs, databases, advertisements, maps and technical drawings, etc.
  2. II) A patent is an exclusive right granted for an invention. Looking at it from a wider view, a patent provides the patent owner with the right to decide how or whether the invention can be used by others.

III) A trademark is a sign capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one enterprise from those of other enterprises. These are the major ranges if intellectual property, amongst others. By striking the right balance between the interests of innovators and the wider public interest, the IP system aims to foster an environment in which creativity and innovation can flourish.

 

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY IN SPACE

As is evident, no intellectual property rights can be claimed yet in Space as such as it is seen historically seen as a common heritage of all of mankind and furthermore the requisites laid down in the OST which mandates the sharing of the benefits of what is derived from Space, individual rights are far from being claimed. It is only on an object that is launched into space can a person/nation have exclusive rights over.  Article VIII of the Outer Space Treaty governs this aspect stating that the launching State has to register the object and in consequence of it, will have jurisdiction over it. In cases where there are two or more launching states, the decision is left to the parties to decide and determine which one of them should have jurisdiction and right over the object. Though the invention is registered and protected under the laws of the nation it is manufactured in, the law which is to govern the activities of such an invention is still a big blank spot.

Today, space technology has become increasingly advanced and developments in this field have resulted in the formation of laws governing outer space and intellectual property rights. Despite the fact that space technology has long been one of the most advanced technical areas in the world, it is only in recent years that intellectual property issues have begun to arise in connection with extraterrestrial activities. Some of the reasons for this are that space activities are increasingly shifting from being state-owned activities to becoming private and commercial activities (Space Exploration Technologies Corp, popularly known as Space X, founded by Elon Musk in the USA in 2002, is a great example).  Many times  creativity result in intangible or intellectual property, which includes          patents,  copyrights,  trademarks and trade secrets. Although  the nationa laws          and international agreements providing for intellectual property protection on earth are well-known and unresolved areas are fairly well-defined but in space, intellectual property protection is subject to greater unknowns. The technology is often novel and the law at best developing.

Further, an increasing number of space activities are operated under international cooperation schemes, which depend on a uniform and reliable international legal framework. In developing and commercializing  any new technology on earth or in space, protection of one’s creativity is vital to success. The international law of outer space is essentially based on the interpretation and implementation of the United Nations’ space treaties. These treaties primarily address governmental activities in space but do not specifically address intellectual property protection, which is very important            for private   sector to get commercially involved in  space activities.  The recognition of the  rights and responsibilities of non-governmental entities  in  space will evolve with increasing activity  by such  entities  in  the  space environment. It determines whether the proposed system conflicts with legal requirements, e.g, a data processing system must comply with the local data protection regulations and if the proposed venture is acceptable in accordance to the laws of the land. Outer space (often referred to as space) consists of a region of universe beyond the upper layers of the atmosphere of Earth. The term is commonly used to distinguish it from airspace and territorial locations. However, the Fédération Aéronautique Internationale has established the Kármán line, at an altitude of about 100 km (~62 mi), to distinguish the boundary separating the working definitions for aeronautics and astronautics.1 Unlike earlier times, space research is not restricted to the government organisations, but has extended to the private players as well. However, the involvement of non-governmental agencies is not in absence of ascertaining any legal liability; Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty, 1967, provides that States shall be responsible internationally for national activities in outer space carried out by governmental agencies or by non-governmental agencies and that the State shall authorize the activities of the non-governmental agencies.

As prescribed in Articles I and II of the Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies (Outer Space Treaty), the exploration and use of outer space for the benefit of mankind and the non-appropriation of outer space by any nation are fundamental principles under international space law. While IP and innovation are of paramount importance for the exploration of outer space and the further development of science and technology, questions have been raised as to whether the protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights may conflict with these fundamental principles.

SOLUTIONS TO CONFLICT BETWEEN INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAWS AND   SPACE LAW

There should be a harmony between the Space laws and the Intellectual property laws. The conflicts between intellectual property and space law regime could be resolved by enacting harmonized system of laws. There are lack of standard rights and liabilities of the IP protection in the space activities. Only by the intellectual property rights the companies can seek protection that adversely expands the commercialization of new inventions. Now there is a need of necessary amendments to the existing space law. Hence, this article discusses about the exercising international and harmonious legal framework of IPR would facilitate maximum collective utilization of public and private resources in the area of space technology Thus, now it is very much necessary to establish and develop a unitary/uniform and harmonised IP protection regime for space for the interest of the developing countries. Outerspace add many new legal dimensions to the IP rights such as  application  of terrestrial based national laws in outer space for acquisition and enforcement of rights, ownership of rights and entitlements for use in joint activities, settlement of disputes and compliance to international obligations. Some developments are taking place at national, regional and multinational levels, to extend the applicability of terrestrial based IP laws in the outer space. Only USA amended its patent  laws extending its  territorial jurisdiction to space. Relevant  provisions for the applicability of domestic IPR law to Space Activities exist only in US law  today, found within the US Space Bill and the NASA act. The US Space Bill extends the applicability of US patent law into OuterSpace. The NASA act includes a provision  to consider a “space object” as a vehicle. Though the regime of intellectual property is governed by national laws, international entities like the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO) and the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) have succeeded in harmonizing the IP laws to some extent, worldwide. However, such a harmonization is not sufficient for extending such protection to space related activities and inventions, thus, the need of the hour is to establish a uniform legislative regime governing IP laws in space so that even the developing countries are able to benefit from their creations rather than being overshadowed by the developed ones. There is a wide scope for several new dimensions pertaining to IP rights that can be opened in the Outer space, such as, application of territory based national laws in outer space for enforcement of rights, entitlement and ownership in case of joint activities, compliance with international obligations, etc. In addition to a uniform legal regime, a standard enforcement mechanism, such as that of International Arbitration, also has to be established to hear and decide disputes arising out of IPR in outer space.

 

 

REFERENCES

http://www.lawjournals.org/archives/2020/vol6/issue1/6-1-64

https://room.eu.com/review/the-protection-of-intellectual-property-rights-in-outer-space-activities

https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/index.html#:~:text=Space%20law%20can%20be%20described,and%20regulations%20of%20international%20organizations.

https://asialaw.tripod.com/articles/ipspacenoichim.html

https://www.wipo.int/aboutip/en/#:~:text=Intellectual%20property%20(IP)%20refers%20to,and%20images%20used%20in%20commerce.

https://intellectual-property-helpdesk.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/ip-and-space-activities-2021-04-29_en

https://www.mondaq.com/india/trademark/762020/intellectual-property-law-and-the-outer-space-a-promising-future-ahead#:~:text=Intellectual%20Property%20Rights%20in%20Space,territorial%20boundaries%2C%20in%20the%20Space.

.brihttps://www.britannica.com/topic/space-law

This painstaking research on intellectual property protection in space was carried out by Stephen Ifeanyichukwu Fortune. Ifeanyi is a law student at the faculty of law, University of Nigeria, Enugu Campus. He has key intrests in IP law, Maritime law, Tax law and Space law. He is an asute researcher who has conducted various researches. He accepts educational criticisms as regards his conducted researches, and you can reach out to him through his email address frezzybest@gmail.com

 

All (Or Most) Lawyers Are Tech Lawyers! By Olumide Babalola

All (Or Most) Lawyers Are Tech Lawyers! By Olumide Babalola

 

Lawyers working within the “tech space” these days are quick to exclusively introduce themselves as “Tech Lawyers.” As catchy and interesting as the title appears, its multi-faceted dimension is often ignored or confused for the creation of a new practice area or a specie of new breed of lawyers.

Surprisingly, this often-bandied contemporary appellation has not enjoyed sufficient analytical (and even academic) attention in spite of its dynamic and robust ramifications. Consequently, when ‘tech law’ is discussed, there is an undue usual fixation on legal services provided on issues concerning robotics, machines and AI at the expense of other areas of the law. This is rather contrary to meaning of technology itself which simply connotes ‘an easier way of achieving certain tasks’.

What is Tech Law?
An inquisition into what Tech Lawyers do must logically commence with an understanding of what ‘tech law’ is. Whether one refers to it as ‘tech law’ or ‘technology law’, its catchment areas are unimaginable wider than its connotative use especially among a certain generation of creative lawyers.

The word ‘technology’ itself is derived from “Techre” – a Greek word which means “art.” Professor A. Zvorikine of the U.S.S.R Academy of Sciences Institute of Philosophy notes that, technology has been defined as the ‘aggregate of techniques diverted towards the attainment of some purpose; specifically, the aggregate of techniques diverted against the forces of nature and towards the modification of materials’ (See A. Zvorikine, ‘Ideas of Technology. Technology and Culture, 443-458).

The erudite professor however observed that the definition as offered by other scholars does not properly capture the material and organic aspect of technology, hence he defines it as “the means of work, the means of human activity developing within a system of social production and social life.”

From the foregoing definitions of technology, then tech law can be simply defined as the body of laws that regulates the deployment of technology. In other words, tech law is the branch of law that regulated the means with which human activities develop within a system. This practice area governs both private and public deployment of technology for certain objectives.
Technology law is (in)explicably wide and complex as it accommodates several other areas of the law to wit; privacy and data protection, information communication technology (ICT), cybercrime, cyber law, artificial intelligence (AI), consumer protection, cyber security, intellectual property, digital rights, digital law, information technology law, fintech, private equity, venture capital, private equity, real estate contracts, contractual transactions, commercial transactions, entertainment, digital assets, cryptocurrency, patent, software licensing, mergers and acquisition, etc the list is open-ended.

What do Tech Lawyers do?
Since we already have an idea of the ambit of tech law, a simplistic and direct answer to what tech lawyers do, would be that: tech lawyers provide legal support/services to technology-related transactions or disputes.

Because of the complex nature of tech law, most commentators are understandably fixated on information technology divide of tech law, hence various commentators on what tech lawyers do have approached the issue from a rather narrow perspective. For example, Angus Finnegan (a partner who heads the International Technology and Telecom group in Reed Smith LLP- a global Law Firm head quartered in United States), argue that tech lawyers assist clients with solving ‘complex technology matters such as software licensing arguments and telecoms contracts? (See ‘Technology law: area of practice’ accessible at <https://targetjobs.co.uk/careers-advice/law/technology-law-area-practice>)
However, Katherine Bishop (another American lawyer) agrees that, from the definition of tech law, tech lawyers function across the broad range of practice area covered by technology law. She argues that a tech lawyer could even function in a financial company advising in regulatory compliance or externally revising the regulatory or contractual implications of technology solutions. Ultimately, she concludes that any lawyer who has advised a client on privacy policy/notice, intellectual property, fintech, even employment contracts is a tech lawyers. Bishop’s position quite rightly captures the organic nature of technology as the means of human productivity within a system. (See ‘What does a tech lawyer do?’ accessible at < https://attorneyatlawmagazine.com/what-does-a-tech-lawyer-do#:~:text=A%20tech%20lawyer%20can%20help,clients%20on%20employee%20classification%20issues.>)

In another rather restrictive article titled ‘The role of a technology lawyer’, Nicholas A. Kees notes that, any lawyer who provides services in relation to protection of ideas, productive and marketing of same, qualifies as a tech lawyer. He recognizes the ‘major’ areas of tech law as intellectual property, competition law, communications and privacy. (accessible at < https://www.gklaw.com/Resources/Documents/KeesEdit3AInsidetheMindsChapterforAspatoreBooks.pdf?)

Interestingly, in June 2021 Bloomberg conducted a survey on ‘Who are tech lawyers? (accessible at < https://news.bloomberglaw.com/bloomberg-law-analysis/analysis-who-are-tech-lawyers-we-asked-them-directly>). The survey did not only reveal that tech law spans almost if not all the law practice areas there is, but that majority of lawyers who have drafted or reviewed (technology-related) contracts would ascribe that appellation to themselves. The survey further revealed that, the regular technology-related matters are privacy, intellectual property, mergers and acquisition, manufacturing and supply agreements, litigation and settlement, employment matters, corporate law matters etc.

Conclusion
From the all-encompassing definition of technology law to the versatility of tech lawyers, it appears all lawyers would have, at one point or another, acted as tech lawyers for their clients. Hence, in my opinion, any lawyer who has drafted or reviewed a contract at any time for his/her career qualifies as a tech lawyer irrespective of the subject matter provided is simplifies the client’s task. Litigation lawyers on the other hand also qualify as tech lawyers since litigation is a pot pouri of many practice areas.

It must be understood at all times that, technology law begins with contracts, hence every lawyer who drafts or reviews a contractual document plays the role of a tech lawyer. Kevin Davis (Professor of Business Law, New York University, school of Law) succinctly put it that:

“If technology means ‘useful knowledge about how to produce things at low cost’, then contracts should qualify. Just as mechanical technologies are embodied in blueprints, technologies of contracting are embodied in contractual documents that serve as blueprint for collaborations.’ (See Kevin E. Davis, ‘Contracts as technology’ (2013) 88(83) New York University Law Review, 83)

Conclusively, if tech law is not exclusive to any practice area, then the description of tech lawyer is not necessarily a separate garment worn by any lawyer acting within the precincts of some limited practice areas erroneously contemplated as constituting technology law. The definition of tech law is too wide and flexible for the exclusive preserve of a sect of lawyers who provide professional services in a hand-picked practice areas.

Let’s Connect Your Law Practice With Clients

Let’s Connect Your Law Practice With Clients

Nigeria has 21 million legal problems each year.

According to the 2018 Justice Needs and Satisfaction report, Nigerians encounter over 57,000 legal problems daily.

Everyday, at Legalnaija we help Nigerians resolve some of these problems by connecting them with expert lawyers or by providing them with information. By doing this, we are solving the problem of access to justice in Nigeria because we believe that a society grounded on the Rule of Law will definitely thrive and succeed.

If you are a lawyer, we will like you to join us in reviving our legal system by assisting citizens in protecting their rights, while also advancing your legal career and attracting new clients to your business. Excitingly, our Directory allows users filter their search for a lawyer via the Lawyer’s location, area of practice and gender.

If interested in this amazing opportunity for personal and national development, kindly ensure you are registered and have a valid subscription on the Lawyers Directory. Subscription is 1,000 Naira for 30 days; 5000 Naira for 6 months, and 10,000 Naira for 1 year.

Kindly note that if you do not have a valid subscription, we shall not be able to refer any briefs to you and clients won’t be able to find you.

If you are having any problem with your registration or subscription or if you want us to activate your subscription, thereby saving you the time, please text the word “Register” or “Subscribe” to 09029755663, or send a mail to hello@legalnaija.com

Remember, we are rooting for you.

Legalnaija Team

How To Mix Business And Pleasure Perfectly

How To Mix Business And Pleasure Perfectly

A lot of business is conducted during unofficial hours and weekends. While enjoying TGIF with friends and partners or having a chat, lots of deals worth billions are being struck over handshakes and champagne toasts.

The problem however is that you always agree to finalise the paper work later on which sometimes can pull the brakes on your business idea and slow things down a lot.

What if you could change that?

What if you could get your contracts and agreements customized to your specifics before you even finish the toast?

On www.legalnaija.com, you can get your legal agreements for a whole lot cheaper, and in less than 5 minutes. Thereby saving you money and keeping the business momentum on full speed. Some of the available Templates include customizable;

1. Contract of Employment

2. Power of Attorney

3. Sales Agreement

4. Licensing Agreement

5. Non – Disclosure Agreements

6. Loan Guaranty Agreement

7. Loan Agreement

8. Uber Commercial Transport Agreement

9. Tenancy Agreement

10. Affidavits and lots more

To customize an Agreement, simply;

1. Visit www.legalnaija.com

2. Select “Draft An Agreement” from the menu list.

3. Choose the Agreement template you need.

4. Answer few questions about your document.

5. Make payment and receive the Agreement in your email immediately.

Our smart contract templates is revolutionizing the way individuals and businesses engage with legal, and this powerful tool is now in your hands.

Are you going to empower yourself and your business?

Legalnaija Team

www.legalnaija.com

Uber/ Bolt Car Owner And Driver Agreements

Uber/ Bolt Car Owner And Driver Agreements

Do you drive a Uber or Bolt (Taxify) or do you own the car being used for a Uber or Bolt service, If yes, do you have a Commercial Driver Agreement?

According to statistics, Uber Nigeria, currently has 9,000 active driver-partners and no fewer than 267,000 monthly rider. This means there a lot of people in the business, and you may already be a party or thinking of getting into the business yourself.

If you are going into the business, especially if you are going in as a Driver of the Vehicle Owner, it is important have an agreement. Such an agreement will help protect both interests of the driver and car owner.

A number of clauses that should be provided for in your agreement include –

  1. Properly identifying the Vehicle
  2. Stating the duration of the agreement
  3. Responsibility for the maintenance and repairs of the vehicle.
  4. Insurance
  5. Storage of the vehicle
  6. Obligations of the parties
  7. Payment schedules
  8. Driver Guarantor
  9. Breach & Termination of the agreement

 

How To Get An Agreement

If you want to get an agreement between a Driver and Vehicle Owner, you can get one in less than 5 minutes on Legalnaija.

Instructions on how to get an Agreement on Legalnaija

  1. Log on to Legalnaija
  2. Select the Uber Commercial Vehicle Agreement from the lists of Templates 
  3. Answer the questionnaire 
  4. Make payment 
  5. Receive your Agreement in your Email. 
  6. Print and sign 
  7. Go on and do business.

Please note that this information is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be legal advice. No lawyer-client relationship is formed nor should any such relationship be implied. It is not intended to substitute for the advice of a qualified lawyer. If you require legal advice, please consult with a qualified lawyer.

 

@Legalnaija

www.legalnaija.com

hello@legalnaija.com

 

How To Get A Tenancy Agreement

How To Get A Tenancy Agreement

A Tenancy Agreement is the agreement between a Landlord and Tenant for the use of a premises for a period of time and for a certain fixed sum. In other words, a Tenancy Agreement is a contract between a Landlord and the Tenant which sets out the rights and obligations of both the Landlord and the Tenant when renting property.

The tenancy agreement lists out all the terms of use agreed to by the parties, and is usually prepared by the Landlord or the Landlord’s lawyer. The type of clauses found in a Tenancy Agreement, usually include;

  • The date the tenancy begins.
  • The names and addresses of the Landlord and the Tenant
  • Address where the property is situated
  • The duration of the tenancy
  • The cost of rent
  • The obligations of the Landlord and Tenant
  • Outline of Bills, the Tenant and Landlord are responsible for during the tenancy period.
  • Mode of termination
  • Service charge and security deposits if applicable
  • Legal fees, and agency fees,

The above list is not exhaustive and in fact there are more terms that are frequently included in well-drafted Tenancy Agreements. It is quite important that Landlords provide Tenancy Agreements for their Tenants, and for Tenants to ensure they study the Tenancy Agreements given to them by the Landlord before signing same.

If you need a Tenancy Agreement, you can customize and download one within minutes on our website, simply login to Legalnaija.

Instructions on how to get an Agreement on Legalnaija

  1. Log on to Legalnaija
  2. Select the Tenancy Agreement from the lists of Templates 
  3. Answer the questtionaire 
  4. Make payment 
  5. Receive your Tenancy Agreement in your Email. 
  6. Print and sign 

Please note that this information is provided for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be legal advice. No lawyer-client relationship is formed nor should any such relationship be implied. It is not intended to substitute for the advice of a qualified lawyer. If you require legal advice, please consult with a qualified lawyer.

 

 

Employment Agreements In Nigeria

Employment Agreements In Nigeria

A contract of employment is a contract between an employer and employee in which the terms and conditions of employment are stated. The term “employee” denotes anyone who is employed under a contract of employment for remuneration and an employer is such person who employs an employee.

An employment contract is an agreement which carries with it an obligation to pay wages in return for service and a corresponding right of control on the part of the employer. Before an employer/employee can make claims under the contract of employment, such party must prove that the existence of a contractual relationship. A contract of employment can be oral, written, or partly oral and written; it may even be inferred or implied from the conduct of the parties, though most contracts of employment are either oral or written.

Usually a contract of employment contains the following clauses;

  1. Name of parties
  2. Address of parties
  3. Date of commencement
  4. Salary and emoluments
  5. Work hours
  6. Non – Compete clauses
  7. Ownership of intellectual property
  8. Vacation and Annual Leaves
  9. Termination of Employment, and much more.

On Legalnaija, you can create and download your own Employment Contracts and Agreement in less than 5 minutes and for a small fee. All you need do is;

  1. Visit https://app.legalnaija.com/shop/templates
  2. Select Tenancy Agreement
  3. Answer the questions
  4. Make payment
  5. Download your agreement

Through this innovation, we have made getting Tenancy Agreements, easier, cheaper and faster. Most especially all our Templates are drafted by expert lawyers.

@Legalnaija

www.legalnaija.com

 

12 New Books For Lawyers In 2022

12 New Books For Lawyers In 2022

If you want to impress your clients and get the briefs pouring in this year, there are 12 books all Nigerian lawyers must have in their library, and the Legalnaija online bookstore has curated these books for you. See the list below;

  1. LISTENEVERYHOW – How Negotiations Work (₦9,800)
  2. Privacy And Data Protection In Nigeria (₦10,000)
  3. The Employment Law Handbook (₦15,000)
  4. The Nigerian Electricity Market; Understanding The Transactional, Legal & Policy Issues (₦35,000)
  5. Understanding Petroleum (Oil & Gas) Transactions and the Nigerian Market (₦50,000
  6. Social Media For Lawyers (2500)
  7. Aviation Law And Practice In Nigeria (₦14,000)
  8. Civil And Criminal Litigation In Nigeria (₦9,500)
  9. Commercial Law And Practice (₦10,000)
  10. Entertainment Law In Nigeria (₦25,000)
  11. Law of Armed Conflict: Principles and Concepts (₦5,000)
  12. The Business of Running Your Business (₦5,000)

You can order any of these books from the convenience of your device and get it delivered to your doorstep easily. All purchases in Lagos are delivered next day, while those outside Lagos are delivered within 1 – 3 working days.

To make your purchase, visit www.legalnaija.com/shop and to chat with a customer care agent, you can call, text or Whatsapp on 09029755663.

Remember, we are rooting for you.

 

 

 

10 Interesting Facts About The 1991 Constitution Of Sierra Leone

10 Interesting Facts About The 1991 Constitution Of Sierra Leone

 

As we celebrate the 30th anniversary of  Sierra Leone’s 1991 national Constitution, here are ten (10) interesting facts about the constitution:

  1. No one can be taken to court for any offence for which he has previously been convicted for by the court. Similarly, if he has been acquitted (freed) by the court from that offence he cannot be taken to court again for the same offence. Section 23(9)

 

  1. The constitution gives every Sierra Leonean the right to bring a court action before the Supreme Court to seek redress if any of their fundamental rights have been infringed upon by any person or institution. Section 28

 

  1. The President of the Republic of Sierra Leone can pardon any person for a crime he/she may have committed if the person has been tried for that crime by the court and found guilty of the said crime. The power is under the prerogative of mercy. Section 40 (4)(e)

 

  1. The constitution states that no person shall hold office as President for more than two terms of five years each, whether or not the terms are consecutive. Section 46(1)

 

  1. The Vice President is the Chairman of the Police Council in Sierra Leone. The Police Council advises the President on all matters relating to the Police, internal security and the appointment of the Inspector General of Police. Section 156 (1)

 

  1. No one can bring a civil or criminal court action against a Member of Parliament because of what the Member of Parliament said during Parliamentary proceedings. Section 99(1)

 

  1.  No one can bring an action against a Judge for any matter or anything he does whilst performing his judicial functions. Section 120 (9)

 

  1. The 1991 constitution states that every court must give judgments or rulings not later than three months after the close of the case and submission of arguments and the court must provide copies of any judgment or ruling delivered to the parties involved.    Section 120 (16)

 

  1. The Supreme Court is the only court which can depart from its previous decisions when it appears right to do so and all other courts are bound to follow its decision.  This means a future Supreme Court can disagree with what the present Supreme Court has held to be the law. Section 122(2)

 

  1.  A Judge shall not while he continues in office as a judge, hold any other office where he will make profit or earn emolument, whether by way of allowances or otherwise, whether private or public, and either directly or indirectly. Section 138(4).

 

Babatunde Johnson is a law graduate from the University of Sierra Leone, Fourah Bay College and he is currently awaiting admission to the Sierra Leone Law School. He is also a legal content creator and Co- Founder at Salone Law Centre.

 

 

Dissenting Judgments: There Can Be No Dissent To The Right To Disagree | Bernard Eldred Jones Esq

Dissenting Judgments: There Can Be No Dissent To The Right To Disagree | Bernard Eldred Jones Esq

 

Every lawyer before the appellate court craves for a consensus from the judges in the panel, this is the norm and dissent is a departure from what is conceived to be the norm. Dissent is not a concept unique only to the legal system, it is part of our daily lives which is why the famous writer Mark Twain said:

“Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect.”

I have on few occasions witnessed the delivery of dissenting judgments and though I am not in agreement with all of them yet I admire the courage to dissent even in the face of probably offending colleagues and those who expect a consensus judgment.

This topic of dissent has always been an enigma to me and as I set on this journey to research on how far and how much our appellate courts have embraced it, I shall first endeavor to address the views of distinguished authors on dissenting judgments.

Former Chief Justice of the United States of America Harlan F. Stone in a letter to the Columbia University in 1928 described dissent in the following manner:

“A dissent in a court of last resort is an appeal to the brooding spirit of the law, to the intelligence of a future day, when a later decision may possibly correct the error in which the dissenting judge believes the court to have been betrayed

 

Judges are not there simply to decide cases, but to decide them as they think they should be decided, and while it may be regrettable that they cannot always agree, it is better that their independence should be maintained and recognised than that unanimity should be secured through its sacrifice.[2]”[Emphasis Mine]

 

I agree with the Learned Chief Justice and as I have seen in cases with dissenting judgment, the dissent points out to the losing party that the judgment may be an error and may be worth another try in a higher court and if not possible, hope that the law will change in the future to reflect the dissent as held by the dissenting judge. A consensus does not give that hope.

 

Louis Blom-Cooper and Gavin Drewry in their 1972 article Final Appeal – ‘A study of the House of Lords in its judicial capacity’[3] described dissent of a final appeal as:

 

“the most apparently poignant judicial tragedy in a legal system founded upon the dramatic conventions of certainty and unanimity”.

 

A strong condemnation indeed, certainly from advocates of unanimity but I do not agree with the view that a dissent signals a judicial tragedy. Their views may seem to my mind to be nothing short of an endorsement of the herd mentality.

 

Justice White in the American Supreme Court case of Pollocks v Farmers Loan and Trust Co. (1895)[4] said:

 

“[the] only purpose which an elaborate dissent can accomplish, if any, is to weaken the effect of the opinion of the majority, and thus engender want of confidence in the conclusion of courts of last resort”.

 

In the case of Liversidge v Anderson and another [1942][5], the majority of the Law Lords gave a judgment by applying a subjective interpretation to the Defence (General) Regulations 1939 thus allowing the Secretary of State to exercise broad powers by detaining anyone he reasonably believes to be a threat to national security.

 

Lord Aitkin disagreed and he gave us what we now have as the most popular dissenting judgment in the commonwealth legal system in the following words:

 

“I view with apprehension the attitude of judges who, on a mere question of construction, when face to face with claims involving the liberty of the subject, show themselves more executive-minded than the executive. Their function is to give words their natural meaning, not, perhaps, in war time, leaning towards liberty…’ in a case in which the liberty of the subject is concerned, we ‘cannot go beyond the natural construction of the Statute.

 

 In this country amidst the clash of arms the laws are not silent. They may be changed, but they speak the same language in war as in peace. It has always been one of the pillars of freedom, one of the principles of liberty for which on recent authority we are now fighting, that the judges are no respecters of persons and stand between the subject and any attempted encroachments on his liberty by the executive, alert to see that any coercive action is justified in law. In this case I have listened to arguments which might have been addressed acceptably to the Court of Kings Bench in the time of Charles I.

 

 I protest, even if I do it alone, against a strained construction put upon words with the effect of giving an uncontrolled power of imprisonment to the Minister. To recapitulate. The words have only one meaning: they are used with that meaning in statements of the common law and in statutes; they have never been used in the sense now imputed to them: they are used in the defence regulations in the natural meaning: and when it is intended to express the meaning now imputed to them, different and apt words are used in the defence regulations generally and in this regulation in particular.” {Emphasis Mine]

 

 

Not swayed by popular opinion or by the persuasion of those who have read his draft[6] and armed with the breastplate of independence, he delivered a dissenting judgment believing he was doing the right thing.

 

He was justified 38 years later, confirming the words of Chief Justice Stone with regards to the hope that someday in the future a later decision may correct the error of the law as the dissenting judge may have opined.

 

Lord Diplock delivering the judgment in Inland Revenue Commission v Rossminister & Others (1980)[7] said:

 

“For my part I think the time has come to acknowledge openly that the majority of this House in Liversidge v. Anderson were expediently and, at that time, perhaps, excusably, wrong and the dissenting speech of Lord Atkin was right.” [Emphasis added]

 

For some practitioners, there is no need to bother with dissenting judgments but I believe a better approach is to read the judgments as a whole and to form your views on the opinion of the Learned Justices. Every Practitioner will understand the beauty of this advice when faced with the dilemma in the case of The Estate of Khalilu Jabbie v Skye Bank (SL) Ltd MIsc. App 45/2014 SLCA (unreported)[8].

 

I am sure many will agree with me that our present legal system is in desperate need of dissenting judgments.  Has that been the case? Have we had enough such dissents to qualify the system to be reflective of judicial independence, freedom of expression and a transparent decision-making process? These are all the questions I might provide answers to in the succeeding parts of this article for we must all agree that the right to disagree is a right that brooks no dissent.

 

In the words of Justice Ginsburg of the US Supreme Court who is known to have written few dissents in a 2009 speech said:

 

 “My experience teaches that there is nothing better than an impressive dissent to lead the author of the majority opinion to refine and clarify her initial circulation.”

 

 

Bernard Eldred Jones Esq is a Barrister and Solicitor in Sierra Leone. He holds a Master of Laws in Banking and Finance Law (UOL), Post Graduate Diploma In Commercial and Corporate Law, Bachelor of Social Sciences specializing in Economics from Fourah Bay College University of Sierra Leone and Bachelor of Laws (LLB) Hons (London)

He was called to the Sierra Leone Bar in 2009. He is a private practitioner.